Paul Goldschmidt’s transition to the New York Yankees has been met with optimism from both his former and current teammates. After six strong seasons with the St. Louis Cardinals, he found himself a free agent due to the team’s rebuilding phase and his declining performance in the 2024 season at age 36.
The Yankees, in search of experienced talent, signed him to a one-year, $12.5 million deal, hoping he could still contribute at a high level. Despite concerns about his age and production, Goldschmidt’s past success and professionalism have many believing he will be a valuable addition to the team.
Goldschmidt’s Late-Season Resurgence and Yankee Stadium’s Favorable Dimensions Boost Expectations
Goldschmidt’s 2024 season raised questions about his ability to perform, particularly after a poor first half where he posted a .664 OPS. However, he made adjustments and significantly improved in the latter half of the season with a .799 OPS.
This resurgence encouraged the Yankees to invest in him, especially given his reliable defense at first base. Former Cardinals manager Oliver Marmol dismissed concerns about Goldschmidt’s age, emphasizing that his struggles were more about mechanical issues in his swing rather than a physical decline.

One factor that could work in Goldschmidt’s favor is Yankee Stadium itself. Former teammate Nolan Arenado noted that Busch Stadium often robbed Goldschmidt of potential home runs due to its deep right-center field. In contrast, Yankee Stadium’s dimensions are expected to benefit his power-hitting style. With the potential for an offensive boost, the Yankees are hopeful that he can regain some of the form that made him the NL MVP in 2022.
Goldschmidt’s Leadership and Experience Strengthen Yankees’ Clubhouse Culture and Team Chemistry
Beyond his performance on the field, Goldschmidt’s leadership qualities make him an invaluable presence in the Yankees’ clubhouse. Arenado believes he is a perfect fit for the team’s culture, while Marmol recalled an instance from 2019 when Goldschmidt paid for a night nurse to support Marmol’s wife while he was on the road for spring training. Such gestures highlight his selflessness and ability to positively impact those around him, reinforcing his reputation as a respected leader.
Goldschmidt’s recent RBI single in a spring training game was an encouraging sign of what he can bring to the Yankees. Manager Aaron Boone has already noted his positive influence, describing him as a player with a strong work ethic and deep knowledge of the game. Boone believes Goldschmidt elevates the team’s overall professionalism, making him a key addition both on and off the field. As the season unfolds, the Yankees will look to him not only for production but also for the leadership qualities that have defined his career.