Three weeks ago, Kyle Shanahan stood on the brink of history, only to be thwarted by an unexpected twist — the surprise onside kick.
Following the controversial decision to kick off after winning the coin toss in overtime against the Chiefs, we speculated about the potential for a bold move akin to Sean Payton’s iconic surprise onside kick in Super Bowl LIV.
However, recent reports suggest that such thrilling moments may soon be a thing of the past. The NFL’s Competition Committee is reportedly finalizing a proposal that would require teams attempting an onside kick to announce their intentions in advance.
While this move aims to address health and safety concerns surrounding kickoffs, it threatens to eliminate one of the most electrifying plays in football.
Some have proposed alternatives, like replacing kickoffs with a fourth-and-long scrimmage play, which would maintain the element of surprise.
Yet, there’s a troubling trend of prioritizing liability and public relations over preserving the essence of the game. While player safety is paramount, altering the game’s fundamental nature raises valid concerns.
The impending rule change marks the first safety-related regulation that sacrifices the excitement that has long defined football. If the NFL continues down this path of drastic alterations, it risks alienating fans and opening the door for competing leagues.
Perhaps it’s time for an alternative, an Old-School Football League, where tradition reigns supreme. While divisive, such a league would undoubtedly capture the hearts of many fans who yearn for the football of yesteryear — a prospect that should give the NFL pause for thought.
