Calls to Trade Paul Skenes Grow, but Pirates Risk Undermining Future by Letting Him Go

Recent discussions have emerged suggesting that the Pittsburgh Pirates should consider trading their star pitching prospect Paul Skenes. This idea, however, is viewed by many as an absurd move that would signal the Pirates’ lack of ambition to compete in the near future. Skenes is seen as a cornerstone of the team’s future, and trading him now would send the wrong message to fans and damage the franchise’s credibility.

Pirates Hold Leverage, but Trade Interest in Paul Skenes Continues to Grow

Paul Skenes remains under team control for several more years, with arbitration not beginning until 2027 and free agency slated for 2030. As long as he doesn’t express dissatisfaction or demand a trade, the Pirates have no compelling reason to move him. With this much control, the organization holds significant leverage, making it unlikely they would part with such a valuable asset without overwhelming returns.

Despite this, ESPN’s Jeff Passan reported that teams are expected to call about Skenes as the trade deadline approaches. He acknowledged that while a trade is unlikely, there is a legitimate argument that moving Skenes now, when his value is at its peak, could be the most strategic long-term move for the Pirates. This has sparked curiosity across the league, especially among teams with strong farm systems.

Cubs Have the Prospects and Motivation to Pursue a Blockbuster Trade for Skenes

Among the teams that might be able to put together a strong offer are the Chicago Cubs. With one of the deeper farm systems in baseball, the Cubs have the assets to potentially make a compelling offer for Skenes. Passan suggested that even if it required parting with all of their top 10 prospects, the Cubs should seriously consider making the call due to what Skenes could bring to their roster.

At just 22 years old, Skenes is already demonstrating ace-level potential, with a fastball that reaches over 100 mph. His blend of youth, elite skill, and long-term team control makes him a highly valuable and rare asset in the league. For a team like the Cubs, acquiring a pitcher of his caliber could address a major need in their starting rotation and strengthen their pitching staff for years, making even a steep trade price something worth considering.