Spring training often serves as a platform for players to refine their skills or secure a spot on the roster. For Guardians’ first baseman Kyle Manzardo, however, this year’s camp brings a new sense of security. After years of striving to break into the majors, Manzardo enters spring training with a guaranteed role as the team’s designated hitter, allowing him to focus on preparation rather than proving himself.
Manzardo expressed a newfound ease during spring training, noting that he feels more relaxed and comfortable compared to the previous year. The 24-year-old’s shift in mindset comes from the assurance of his position, a stark contrast to 2023, when he was battling for a roster spot. His journey to this point has been anything but smooth, involving a midseason trade from the Tampa Bay Rays to the Guardians in exchange for Aaron Civale.
Manzardo Overcomes Early Struggles, Adjusts to DH Role, and Refines Approach
Following his trade, Manzardo performed exceptionally well at Triple-A, posting a .256/.348/.590 slash line with six home runs and 16 RBIs in just 21 games. Despite his promising numbers, he began the 2024 season in the minors due to roster competition. However, his strong performance continued, as he hit .267 with 20 home runs and demonstrated improved plate discipline throughout 83 games.
Manzardo’s initial call-up to the major leagues did not go as planned. In 29 games, he struggled at the plate, hitting just .207 with no home runs and experiencing an uncharacteristically high strikeout rate. His approach at the plate became too aggressive, and his fly ball rate increased significantly, leading to subpar results. Additionally, his transition to a designated hitter role presented unexpected mental challenges.
Kyle Manzardo (MLB)Guardians manager Stephen Vogt acknowledged that the transition from playing first base daily to primarily serving as a DH created difficulties for Manzardo. The lack of regular defensive duties made the mental aspect of the game more demanding. Manzardo himself admitted that adjusting to the mental toll of being a DH required significant effort, as it forced him to think about the game differently than he had in the past.
Beyond on-field challenges, Manzardo also faced the additional pressures of being a major league player, including increased media attention and higher expectations. After struggling in his initial stint, he returned to Triple-A, where he regained his rhythm and confidence. This experience provided valuable lessons that he applied when he received another call-up later in the season.
Manzardo Poised for Breakout Season After Strong Finish and Veteran Mentorship
When given another chance in September, Manzardo capitalized on the opportunity, hitting .270 with five home runs in 23 games. His improved walk rate and barrel rate indicated that he was becoming more comfortable at the plate. These adjustments helped him regain his approach, allowing him to be more selective with his swings while maintaining his power output.
Manzardo’s strong finish to the 2024 season fueled his motivation during the off-season. He dedicated himself to further improvement, believing he now truly belongs at the major league level. His coach, Vogt, echoed this sentiment, praising Manzardo’s work ethic and performance throughout spring training
A key addition to the Guardians’ roster this offseason was veteran Carlos Santana, who provides valuable mentorship for Manzardo. Santana, a seasoned first baseman, has already begun guiding Manzardo, offering insights on approach and preparation. This mentorship extends to defensive work, where Manzardo has made strides, particularly in improving his throwing mechanics.
With a secured role and newfound confidence, Manzardo enters the 2025 season with high expectations. He is projected to hit around .260 with 20 home runs and a solid RBI total in the middle of the Guardians’ lineup. While he remains underdrafted in fantasy leagues, his improved performance suggests he could exceed expectations and become a valuable contributor at the MLB level.
