Joel Bitonio, the Cleveland Browns guard, is uncertain about whether he will continue his career into the 2025 season. As the offseason approaches, Bitonio revealed that he is still “working through” his decision, describing the process as a “roller coaster” filled with conflicting thoughts. His deliberation is influenced by both physical and emotional factors, as well as the current state of the Browns franchise.
Joel Bitonio’s Durability and Decision: Physical Toll, Injuries, and Team’s 2024 Performance
Bitonio has been remarkably durable throughout his career, playing in 15 or more games each season since 2016. However, injuries have taken their toll on him, as he regularly plays through various ailments. He openly discussed how his knee, elbow, and shoulder may never fully recover, acknowledging the immense physical strain of the offensive line position. Similar to other veterans like former Eagles center Jason Kelce, Bitonio has relied on medication to manage the pain and continue playing.

Bitonio’s decision is also influenced by the Browns’ performance in the 2024 season. The team’s disappointing campaign has left fans and some players, including star Myles Garrett, feeling disillusioned.
Garrett’s trade request further complicated the situation, though Bitonio emphasized that Garrett’s situation would not directly impact his decision. While Bitonio primarily focuses on his personal well-being, he also acknowledges that the team’s competitiveness plays a role in his choice, referencing the uncertainty of entering a potential rebuild.
Joel Bitonio’s Potential Retirement: A Distinguished Legacy and Future Uncertainty with Browns
Should Bitonio decide to retire, he will leave behind a distinguished legacy with the Browns. With seven Pro Bowl selections, two All-Pro honors, and over 160 games played, Bitonio has firmly established himself as one of the top guards in the NFL. His career trajectory mirrors that of other elite players from his draft class, such as Aaron Donald and Zack Martin, both of whom have recently retired. Bitonio recognizes that retirement is a possibility, especially as he sees other standout players concluding their careers.
Bitonio has stated that his decision will come soon, and he trusts in the Browns’ front office, led by General Manager Andrew Berry and head coach Kevin Stefanski, to build a competitive team for the 2025 season. Despite the uncertainties surrounding the team’s future and his own physical condition, Bitonio remains hopeful that the Browns will return to playoff contention. Whether or not he continues playing in 2025 will depend on a combination of his physical health and the direction of the team.