Vikings Yet to Name J.J. McCarthy as Starting QB, Keeping Competition Open

J.J. McCarthy
J.J. McCarthy (NFL)

Minnesota Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy made headlines with his recent statement that he has not been officially informed he will be the team’s starting quarterback heading into training camp.

Despite the departures of both Sam Darnold and Daniel Jones in free agency earlier in March, the Vikings have yet to formally anoint McCarthy as their QB1. The 2024 first-round pick missed his entire rookie season due to a full meniscus repair, leaving questions about his readiness and status within the team.

Vikings Prioritize Competition, Making McCarthy Earn Starting Job After Losing Veterans

NFL insider Albert Breer of Sports Illustrated reported that Minnesota had attempted to retain both Darnold and Jones, making “substantial offers” before ultimately letting them walk. Breer suggested that the team wants McCarthy to earn the starting job rather than handing it to him by default, given the crucial development time he lost due to injury.

J.J. McCarthy
J.J. McCarthy (NFL)

While Breer still believes McCarthy will eventually be the starter, he emphasized that a competitive environment in training camp would be beneficial for the young quarterback and the team. The Vikings’ decision not to match substantial contracts for Darnold and Jones highlights their commitment to a fresh start.

Darnold secured a lucrative three-year, $100.5 million deal with the Seattle Seahawks, while Jones signed a one-year, $14 million contract with the Indianapolis Colts, where he will compete with Anthony Richardson for the starting job. By allowing both quarterbacks to leave, Minnesota appears focused on evaluating McCarthy, though they may still explore veteran options.

Vikings Weigh Veteran Options Amid McCarthy’s Uncertain Starting Quarterback Status

Reports from ESPN’s Kevin Seifert suggest that Minnesota is keeping its options open, including a potential pursuit of Aaron Rodgers if the veteran remains unsigned after mandatory minicamp. If Rodgers were to join the team, McCarthy’s opportunity to “earn” the starting job would likely vanish, as acquiring the future Hall of Famer would signal a win-now approach.

Additionally, Russell Wilson remains an option if he does not land with the New York Giants or Cleveland Browns, though he would not be guaranteed the starting role like Rodgers likely would be.

Vikings general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah is scheduled to speak with local reporters on Wednesday, potentially providing insight into McCarthy’s role heading into the offseason program.

Until then, the team’s quarterback situation remains fluid, with McCarthy’s performance in spring and summer workouts likely determining whether he will be named the official starter. The Vikings appear committed to fostering competition, ensuring that their next starting quarterback is fully prepared to lead the team.